Sign up        Name or E-mail: Pw: [Forgot Password]
Members

Now online
Member search
New members
Latest comments

Comment Spy
Forums
Week by week
Baby development
Latest photos

Pregnancy
Babies
Bellies
Ultrasound
Member pages
Latest Updates

Blogs & Questions
Updated profiles

staceyh`s poll Show results | Hide results


Baby-poll poll Do you think it is wrong for the state to remove your child because of his/her name??
(Baby poll by staceyh, 1127 days ago)
yes
no


Vote to see the results

Comments: 14

Emauk (774.7 days ago)
I didn`t hear about this..must be in America..but I don`t think you should remove a child from it`s parents purely on a name choice..after all it is just a name..some letters on a piece of paper..I do think it is a very bad name choice though..and they should be made to change it..also to be watched closely..but if the child is not in any danger then they should leave them with there parents..

alex76 (1126 days ago)
There must be more to this but would that surprise you given that name. What kind of parent's would do such a thing. As Danielle said, hardly the ideals of a good parent. Poor kid.

mamamia76 (1126.4 days ago)
There HAS to be more of a reason than the names that actually places the children in danger if they stay with their parents, as Holly28 said. There is NO WAY that was why they were taken.

Holly28 (1126.5 days ago)
I have worked in Child Protection. I am very confident that there is more to this story than has been released. There are strict guidelines as to what does and doesn`t justify removing a child from the home.

military~mommy (1126.6 days ago)
His Father does not believe the holocaust was real, ULGH!

military~mommy (1126.6 days ago)
I believe there is more to this story than is being released. Often, if there is abuse involved, the police will not release the details until the case is heard in court and a prosecutor agrees to try the case, for fear of libel. Tho I must wonder what sadistic tendencies these parents must harbor.

danielle007 (1126.6 days ago)
Where I live here in Quebec, the state can reject a name and it has done. If they find the name unacceptable they will force the parents to choose one that they do find acceptable. On the other hand one has to wonder how parents who name their child Adolph Hilter will raise this child. Can you imagine their life philosophy??

annas-momma (1126.6 days ago)
Yes I heard about the child being named Adolf Hitler. He has an older sister named Arien Nation. However, I believe they were taken away for reasons more than their names...

his1-n-only (1126.6 days ago)
dang at first i didnt know what the crap you were talking about, i thought it must have been a typo or something...but i read the comments. WHO...IN THEIR RIGHT MIND would name their child Adolf Hitler? they must be wacko`s. but i dont think the child should be taken away...

lovemyfamily (1126.6 days ago)
I think the state should legally force them to change a name like that, yes. A child will be victimized his entire life for something like that! I also think that the parents should be watched closely, but everyone should be given a chance to become a parent. It`s disgusting what they did, but the child is not being abused, from what we can see.

monkeymamma (1126.6 days ago)
It`s none of their business what people name their children. Their jobs are to protect children from abusive situations or any other situations that are harmful. But shame on the parents for choosing names like that.

wisfarmgirl (1126.6 days ago)
That is a severely poor choice of a name, but that is not grounds for government involvement.

RobinG (1126.6 days ago)
This a yes or no, it has lots of gray areas to it..it is a `depends on the name` answer ~ since I know the one you may be referring to I`d say yes ~ makes me sick they named their child that. Although they claim that isnt the reason they were removed.

staceyh (1126.6 days ago)
I read the news about the little boy being removed from his home because his parents named him Adolf Hitler...I don`t care for the name but all three of my kids have bible names...is there coming a day where they could be taken??? ummm very disturbing to me....



Add comments


Sign up to be able to leave comments!
(Sign up)

Recent polls
  1. I`ve re-thought the moderating of the member-postings. How does this sound? Let`s change it to usage, rather than length of time as a member. Say your first 10 or 20 polls, questions and pictures need to be approved by a Mod or something like that. Someone posting the racist polls and adding the kiddie porn is unlikely to participate as a normal member. Once you are verified as a regular member you`re no longer monitored.
  2. How long did it take you to get pregnant after you got your IUD (Mirena) out?
  3. Twilight valentines for 7 year olds... appropriate or not? DD received a valentine with a very... sultry smoldery Edward on the front and I was just kind of surprised that anyone would buy those for 7 year olds? I know I`m on the conservative side in general on those kinds of things, but this really surprised me!
  4. My daughter is almost 5 months and 3 weeks ago my hair started falling out. I know it`s normal but how long did it last for you?
  5. With all the issues going on with the site maybe we need an updated list on Mods. Obviously Laura is the one to go to but if there is a concern and it needs immediate attention and a Mod is online it may be good to know who is who so you can reach out to them. Mods, can you please post here so we know who you are. (Esp since some profiles names had to be changed because of recent log on issues)
  6. Anyone wanna try http://parentspuzzlepieces.spruz.com/ a free community site I just made? Let me know if you want the password and would want to help add things to it!!
  7. I think with all the posting issues IAP needs to appoint someone to verify all pictures, polls, questions, etc that are posted by new members. Sure, it`ll probably make things slower, but something needs to be done! Many websites have this installed and IAP needs it as well. Members that have been on the site for a certain time can be exempt, but if you are a new member, posts should be monitored. I`m going to copy this suggestoin to Laura and if you agree you should too!! :)
  8. MODS ~ please help me in monitoring the photo pages and other pages. Horrific porn was posted in photos sections and they need to be deleted as soon as they are seen. I reported it to Laura also. TX!!
  9. my 4 yr old has 3 planter warts on his foot,.. any home remedies gals or is this a dr visit?
  10. ok ladies, sry its long but i really need some advice, a year ago my 5 yr old brother was diagnosed with type 1 diabetes, over the last year my mom has had a hard time dealing with his diagnosis because there is no cure and all she can do is give him 5 insulin shots a day to keep him alive, she looks at it like march 13th 2011 was the death of her healthy little boy and she woke up with this sick child, well i always tell her she needs to go to counseling to learn how to cope with this but lately i`m more worried about my baby brother, he came home the other day from kindergarten and had a picture of a red headed boy with a knife, 3 people under the ground dead and another one on top of the ground covered in blood, he recently grabbed one of my 15 yr old brother`s pocket knives out and started swinging it at my older brother because they were fighting, and then he told my mother he wanted to be a serial killer when he grows up! he has said before that he wishes he would die, that he didn`t want to wake up the next morning,..... (more inside)